Skip to content

Simplifying The Choice Between Custom vs. Boxed ERP Solution 

Simplifying The Choice Between Custom vs. Boxed ERP Solution

If you are running a growing business, it makes sense to implement ERP software (aka Enterprise Resource Planning software. ERP makes routine tasks easier by gathering, storing, managing, and communicating departmental information in a single database. However, selecting and implementing it according to the demands of your industry could be difficult. Enterprise Resource Planning, or ERP, is an exceptional software solution with several modules and linked operations that serve the entire company. As a result, performance and efficiency both rises. Most organizations find the process of implementing ERPs to be daunting at first because of the significant software and high cost involved. The most challenging aspect of the installation process is selecting an appropriate ERP Solution and an efficient implementation strategy. Knowing everything that organizations dread and question, what happens if they spend money on inefficient ERP and it fails? Or if they must choose between a custom and a boxed ERP. We are here to simplify your ERP implementation path and decision-making by offering comprehensive ERP guidance and the benefits and cons of custom and boxed ERP.  

In-depth exploration of Custom and Boxed ERP Solutions 

Businesses implement ERP to streamline business operations and ensure the organization moves toward success and growth. Efficiency in managing routine functions and providing transparent information to everyone saves time and money. But it could be very stressful if, after spending a lot of time and money in implementing this project, it leads to failure, or you couldn’t meet your needs – streamlining the processes. So, to save yourself from this disaster of a wrong decision, you need to follow the step-by-step ERP implementation process. Additionally, understand the types of ERPs and which ones will be suitable for you. Before going further, you must be pretty much clear about what custom and boxed ERPs are.   

Custom ERP with its Pros and Cons 

Custom ERP solution is software created from scratch for a specific industry or business. Before custom software development, companies must gather all the necessary information, including business requirements, functional domains, and additional modules they desire to include in their ERP system. Custom ERP solutions provide exceptional flexibility and tailored functionalities. One of the key benefits is the ability to perfectly match the system with unique processes, giving you a competitive advantage. Scalability is made more accessible by customization, ensuring that the ERP system expands together with the company. 

Nevertheless, there are drawbacks to this degree of customized sophistication. Custom solutions sometimes need higher initial expenditure, and the development process might be lengthy. Maintenance and upgrades may also necessitate specific skills. 

Businesses must thoroughly understand their needs and requirements before reviewing the selection criteria. You need to work internally, among C-level executives, the heads of every department, and other senior employees’ advice matters. Come up with a complete plan and information on where you want to implement your ERP, what departments and modules you need to connect, which parts you want to automate, and what your expectations are from ERP. After all the details and goals, examine the different types of ERPs with their pros and cons to ensure which fits best with your unique requirements. 

The following are the benefits and shortcomings of Custom ERP: 


  • Tailored Solutions: Precision in meeting specific business requirements.  
  • Competitive Edge: Customization for a unique market advantage will give the edge over competition. 
  • Scalability: Flexibility to grow in tandem with business expansion. Business will have ability to quickly scale the software functions along with changes in dynamic business needs.  
  • Optimized Processes: Efficient workflows aligned with organizational needs. Businesses are NOT changing their process to meet the use of software. The major advantage is that the custom software is developed to fit with the current business process that brought the success and add enhancements identified during the course. 
  • Enhanced Data Security: Customized security measures for sensitive information can be done. 
  • Negligible cost of Training: The success of any software lies in how command fully the employees can use it. The greater the knowledge the staff have knowledge the more eager they use it and thus the organization can reap the reward of it. 


Higher Initial Investment: Increased upfront costs for development. Although, this option appears as capital intensive, one can see that cost of implementation and loss of productivity coupled with cost of training the staff is a good chunk of money that can be seen as saving in case of custom developed ERP software.  

  • Extended Development Time: Customization can prolong the implementation process. This can be a painstakingly long period.  
  • Specialized Maintenance: Ongoing IT consulting services may require more knowledge and maintenance. 
  • Potential for Over-customization: Excessive features may complicate rather than simplify. The role of business analysis team and guidance from management team can curtail the scopecreep.  
  • Dependency on Developers: Reliance on external expertise for updates and modifications.  
  • Risk of Failure: As designed from scratch, no efficient testing is available; first usage gives the best results. 


Boxed ERP with its Pros and Cons 

Boxed or off-the-shelf ERP solutions are pre-built software that provides all the ERP capabilities ready to deploy. It allows you to implement an ERP system quickly and affordably. They are pre-packaged with standardized features, perfect for enterprises with basic requirements. These are well-tested and verified, ready for installation. The essential advantage is the low cost and speed of deployment. However, boxed solutions may lack flexibility, forcing firms to change their operations to meet the software. 


  • Cost-Effective: Lower upfront costs and rapid implementation. 
  • Quick Deployment: Ready-to-use solutions for immediate integration. 
  • Vendor Support: Ongoing support and updates provided by the vendor. 
  • Standardized Features: Well-defined functionalities suitable for everyday needs. 
  • Community Resources: Access to a community of users for shared insights.


  • Lack of Customization: Limited ability to tailor features to specific needs. 
  • Adaptation Required: Business processes may need adjustment to fit the software. This can be a pretty expensive task and is very invisible in nature.  
  • Scalability Challenges: Limited flexibility for future growth, as it can’t be customized per the organization’s future growth. 
  • Dependency on Vendor: Reliance on the vendor’s development and update schedule. 
  • Potential Overhead: Businesses may have to pay additional costs for features that may not be relevant. And the cost of adding the features needed can be more expensive and takes an extreemly longer period.  
  • Risk of losing opportunities: Businesses may experience the lose of opportunities due to lack of required tools and features in boxed software.  

Strategic Comparison for Optimal Choices 

When strategically comparing custom and boxed ERP solutions, businesses should weigh factors such as the level of customization required, scalability needs, and budget constraints. Custom ERP is ideal for those seeking tailored solutions and has the resources for a more extended development cycle. Boxed ERP suits businesses looking for immediate implementation at a lower cost but with less flexibility. A thorough evaluation considering long-term goals, industry-specific requirements, and available resources will guide businesses to make an optimal choice. 

Final Thoughts 

In a nutshell, there is no one-size-fit approach to meeting the demands of various businesses. Know your industry correctly and choose the ERP that best meets your demands, as these are not the best or worst options. The decision between custom and boxed ERP hinges on each business’s unique needs, priorities, and circumstances. Whether opting for tailored sophistication or quick deployment, a smart decision will set the foundation for efficient operations and sustained growth.